43 responses

  1. Alicia
    03/25/2016

    5 stars
    Made it! So easy and delicious. Another great weekday dinner idea. Thanks for sharing!

    Reply

  2. Brandy
    10/05/2016

    5 stars
    I am anything but a cook and attempted this recipe. It was excellent, thank you! The only minor changes I made was I didn’t brown the meat first and it only took 7 hours in my crock pot (I’m sure cooking times vary). My husband, who is usually the cook, was impressed too. It was easy, thank you for sharing!

    Reply

    • Laree
      10/10/2016

      What type of round steak did you use? I didn’t realize there were so many choices, top round, bottom round…

      Reply

      • Linda
        01/22/2023

        I realize these comments are very old, but did anyone figure out what type of round to use?

        Reply

      • Kate Sorensen
        01/23/2023

        Hi Linda,

        A rump roast, or even a chuck roast would bo good choices.

        Kate

        Reply

  3. Tobie
    10/10/2016

    Making this tonight but instead of using fresh onions and peppers going to use a bag of pepper stirfry. Can’t wait to try it!

    Reply

  4. Kim
    01/14/2017

    Three boys LOVED it! I added 1/4 stick butter and omitted additional salt. Outta this world using half off prime rib on sale that was cut to suit recipe.

    Reply

    • Tami Classen
      11/01/2018

      Where did you add the 1/4 stick butter to……or did you use it on the bread?

      Reply

  5. Betty Starkey
    02/04/2017

    This is a great recipe!! You can also freeze the mixture if you don’t use it all !! It’s awesome when unexpected company comes. Just defrost, heat , add cheese voila!!

    Reply

  6. Jane
    02/24/2017

    5 stars
    We tried this and we loved it!

    Reply

  7. Whitney
    04/19/2017

    5 stars
    A great recipe for sure. The meat falls apart and blends with onions and peppers perfectly. Made my house smell amazing. And of course, very tasty! Thanks for sharing ☺

    Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      01/24/2018

      Hey Whitney! Glad you loved it!

      Kate

      Reply

  8. Linda
    11/18/2017

    This was really great followed exactly except I used no salt beef broth and garlic powder

    Reply

  9. OhioWolverine
    02/11/2018

    5 stars
    Excellent! Here is a little tip: to make slicing the meat a bit easier, freeze it for an hour or so first. I used 1 tsp garlic powder in lieu of 3 tsp garlic salt. Perfect!! Thanks for sharing!

    Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      02/23/2018

      Glad you liked it and thank you for the tip!

      Reply

      • Linda
        03/03/2019

        Actually there is usually enough liquid left you can make Veggie Beef soup the next day. When I buy the ingredients I also buy a frozen bag of mixed veggies. EM EM GOOD

        Reply

      • Kate Sorensen
        03/06/2019

        Glad you enjoyed this Linda!

        Kate

        Reply

  10. Daphne
    07/18/2018

    5 stars
    What a terrific recipe! It tasted just like one I would get at a Restaurant! It actually made 2 meals since there are only 3 of us. I WILL be making this again and again!

    Reply

  11. Alicia
    01/17/2019

    This looks good for sure, but it is NOT a Philly cheesesteak! Philly cheesesteaks never have peppers (where this came from, I’ll never know) and they certainly don’t have Italian seasoning. But it does look delicious and I’ll definitely try it – I just won’t tell my born-and-raised Philly family that it’s supposed to be a Philly cheesesteak 🙂

    Reply

  12. Cindy
    04/14/2019

    It’s been in the crockpot 5 hours and it’s very runny!!

    Reply

    • Sunny
      04/19/2019

      It calls for 8 hours of cook time. Maybe try cooking it the entire time before complaining?

      Reply

  13. Elaine Wolfe
    06/20/2019

    We loved it!

    Reply

  14. Locanto
    09/10/2019

    Glad you liked it and thank you for the tip!

    Reply

  15. RICHARD
    01/15/2020

    Can you prepare this in the crock pot after it has been cooked the next day for company keeping it on low before searving company?

    Reply

  16. Yaina
    08/24/2020

    Your post PHILLY CHEESE STEAK RECIPE IN THE CROCK POT is really amazing I love to read your article. I bookmark your website to view more articles. Thanks for this.

    Reply

  17. Nancy
    08/24/2020

    5 stars
    Easy & delicious. Definitely a keeper and will be added to my recipe collection.

    Reply

  18. Pallavi Dutta
    02/06/2021

    I have read this Post and it provide details information about the topic which is really helpful for the readers

    Reply

  19. asharma1
    11/27/2021

    Thank you administrator for offering to us such helpful data

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Back to top
mobile desktop