138 responses

  1. Cynthia
    05/24/2017

    I would like to know can this be done with a from scratch recipe for the cake and frosting I don’t give my grandkids cake mixes

    Reply

    • Clarissa Moore
      05/27/2017

      What’s so wrong with cake mix, your kids to good for it?

      Reply

      • Debbie
        06/04/2017

        I never use mixes, either. Most things taste better from ‘scratch’. I was just raised that way. My recepie only takes 45 minutes to cook in an oven.

        Reply

      • Lynda
        08/23/2017

        I have a microwave recipe from Pampered Chef and it takes15 minutes to make.

        Reply

      • Steff
        11/07/2017

        Will you please share the recipe?
        Thanks

        Reply

      • Connie
        03/31/2019

        Lynda I would like the microwave recipe please ????

        Reply

      • Jo45
        08/18/2017

        ‘too’. If you’re going to insult someone, do it in proper English.

        Reply

      • Sandy
        09/25/2017

        Who died and made you the spelling police?

        Reply

      • Alice
        11/15/2017

        WELL, anybody who payed attention to any English class or even popular memes on the internet will know the difference between “to, too, and two” as the same as “there, they’re, and their.”
        So next question is why make a comment to start something if you’re not willingly to finish it?

        Reply

      • Rooney1943
        11/18/2017

        Yes!

        Reply

      • Susan
        08/18/2017

        Seriously? This comment was certainly not necessary. She just asked a question.

        Reply

      • James Williams
        09/27/2017

        Clarissa Moore some Cake mixes have chemicals in them that aren’t necessarily good for you and some of us avoid them when possible.
        Cynthia in answer to your question, sense no one seemed to want to answer it, yes you can do it from scratch. You might want to make the icing just a little thicker than you normally do sense it is going to be heated. I’m a scratch baker too and I know where you are coming from.

        Reply

      • Dee Goebel
        01/11/2023

        “sense” – “since”
        If I make it, I will use a cake mix. At age 80 and healthy–I’ve lived a long and healthy life! Why be concerned about a mix versus scratch now?

        Reply

      • Jan Rhodes
        12/04/2017

        Not Nice!

        Reply

      • Michelle
        01/22/2018

        going to try this without the frosting but maybe a few chocolate chips. Thanks for sharing

        Reply

      • Cindy s Reynolds
        04/17/2019

        instead of frosting….use chocolate pudding…..that is how I always make it….

        Reply

      • Donna
        03/01/2020

        That sounds yummy

        Reply

      • Paula
        01/27/2018

        That’s just rude. A lot of people cook from scratch and it’s not because they are too good for box mixes. Scratch actually taste better.

        Reply

      • Javante
        02/28/2018

        *too

        Reply

      • Jolie
        03/16/2018

        5 stars
        Actually any time you can make something without all the extra added ingredients you are putting a better product in your body. Good job grannie!

        Reply

      • Kathy
        04/02/2019

        Wow
        ….what a smarta** answer, scratch is always tastier AND perhaps she doesn’t want her kids eating all the chemicals and coloring from a boxmix….you need to change your attitude or stay off here….you wanna fight someone with your words, go elsewhere, this isn’t the forum!

        Reply

      • Donna
        03/01/2020

        Lord… Some people just take the fun out of everything….

        Reply

      • Angie
        01/12/2021

        They probably have allergies. Alot of kids or people can’t eat cake mixes because they are made where peanut products are also made close in the vicinity and some people are highly allergic.

        Reply

    • Michaelann Dahlman
      06/30/2017

      Cynthia, I would suspect that any similar sized cake recipe would work just as well. Probably the icing, too. But its difficult to say for sure. I might try this sometime, I’ll let you know if it works from scratch as well.

      Reply

    • James Williams
      01/08/2018

      Sense you pre-make the cake mix their is no reason a home made cake from scratch shouldn’t work.

      Reply

    • Raquel
      01/26/2018

      Any flavor icing will do. I used a salted caramel as this is too much chocolate for us.

      Reply

      • lynn
        01/26/2018

        How did this turn out? I’m thinking about using vanilla.

        Reply

    • Theresa Williamson
      01/27/2018

      Make you from scratch cake and put it into the crock with your own butter cream frosting and chocolate chips.

      Reply

    • michael grant
      01/03/2019

      Would you cook this on high, med or low???

      Reply

      • vangie bolio
        03/01/2019

        i’d love to try this recipe . what setting would you cook it At ? thanks for this wonderful recipe !!

        Reply

      • Valli Garza
        12/13/2019

        I’m wondering that too. I just opened my cake mix to make it and realized that it doesn’t say what setting to cook it on.

        Reply

      • Stephanie McAfee
        01/23/2021

        5 stars
        You cook it on high for 2 to 2 1/2 hours Hun…
        Good luck…

        Reply

      • Amanda
        09/03/2023

        That was my question, too. Glad I looked at the comments because I had it on low. Thanks!

        Reply

    • Jennifer Beaury
      05/01/2019

      There is nothing wrong with doing things from scratch and your correct they taste better and less preservatives. Unfortunately life has become much more hectic and many people have less time to doing things from scratch. I commend you for taking the time. Good for you.

      Reply

    • Nicole
      08/09/2019

      The best homemade chocolate cake recipe is this one: https://sugarspunrun.com/easy-chocolate-cupcakes/

      Reply

    • cindy
      03/31/2024

      Yes, you can use homemade cake for this.

      Reply

  2. JENNIFER HAYTON
    05/25/2017

    hi i have not seen the frosting in South Africa. Is it a normal thick icing that you use to decorate a cake?

    Reply

    • Billie tyree
      05/29/2017

      Yes

      Reply

    • Leandrie
      12/25/2017

      You can purchase it at checkers or pick ñ pay

      Reply

  3. Molly
    05/25/2017

    How do you think this would turn out if you used a different flavor icing? Say, vanilla or butter cream?

    Reply

    • JCNana
      07/11/2017

      Then it’s not a traditional lava cake. Do whatever you want!

      Reply

    • Mike
      12/11/2017

      Or how about using peanut butter chips!

      Reply

    • Leandrie
      12/25/2017

      Doesn’t have the same effect as the chocolate icing. Tried it last night and wasn’t as good.

      Reply

  4. Jane
    05/25/2017

    Can this be made in a regular oven, I don’t have a crockpot

    Reply

    • James Williams
      09/27/2017

      Yes. Set your oven at 300 F and it should work. At about 2 hrs you might want to start checking it ovens cook differently.

      Reply

  5. JCNana
    07/11/2017

    Good grief, people! She was providing an easy recipe for people to try. You want to do “scratch,” do it but don’t be judgmental. And don’t be stupid! Of course, scratch would work and of course an oven would work!!!!! Again, she was just providing an easy thing for people to try…..or not.

    Reply

    • Sheesh
      08/09/2017

      LOL! I agree!

      Reply

      • BeeBee
        08/17/2017

        LOL; true. Good Luck to all; the recipe sounds yummy. I have recently started trying recipes in my crock pot and am excited to try this one! 😉 Blessings!

        Reply

      • recipe seeker
        09/26/2017

        Me too, looking at a simple recipe became a bit stressful just reading the comments. For good
        ness sake!

        Reply

      • Sharon
        09/27/2017

        Always looking for new recipes to try in the crock pot. I agree with you on the comments,

        Reply

      • ginger
        01/04/2018

        some people will make a federal case out of anything! Either try it or don’t, no need to make a big issue out of it.

        Reply

    • sally
      01/24/2018

      5 stars
      You are so right. I don’t know why some people think they need to criticize when someone asks a simple question. I appreciated the recipe and am anxious to try it, maybe next family dinner.

      Reply

    • Karla Hoskins
      02/08/2018

      Yes, I agree ! It a cake recipe! Some folks like it one way , others a different way! Who knows a change might come up with a totally different yummy dessert!

      Reply

    • Jerry
      01/25/2019

      I totally agree with you I’m going to make it tomorrow Thanks for sharing this easy recipe

      Reply

  6. Gay Harlander
    07/12/2017

    JCNana, I’m with you! My granddaughter want chocolate cake and vanilla ice cream for her BD and since we are living in our RV for the moment I don’t want to heat it up with the oven so I am using the crockpot. This is the one she will get and I’ll bet she will love it.

    Peeps, take it for what it’s worth. Quick and easy! Especially for Bakersfield, CA when the temp here today is 103 and expected to reach 108 later this week!

    Reply

    • Leilani
      01/31/2018

      The unwavering oven and such can bake a cake. I used one for quite sometime when my oven died. No heat in kitchen. Use it several times a week in summer living in Arizona

      Reply

  7. Lucky
    07/13/2017

    Is it 2 hours on high?

    Reply

    • Heather
      07/27/2017

      It is 2.5 hours on high, I missed it the first time through as well but I found it. 🙂

      Reply

      • Penny
        12/09/2017

        I wondered if it’s actually 2 hrs as in the directions at the end it shows to cook it for 1 hr…..

        Reply

  8. Debbie
    07/14/2017

    I think this looks Great, I’m so glad you added the video.Thank you so much for posting it.

    Reply

  9. Joyce
    07/25/2017

    I have a crockpot with actual temperatures. What do you suggest? 400° is the highest which seems pretty high for 2.5 hours cooking time. Thanks!

    Reply

    • Laurie
      07/25/2019

      Did you find out how temperature ?? I am planning to making tomorrow

      Reply

  10. Jennifer
    08/02/2017

    Could I add maraschino Cherries to the recipe? I was thinking of draining a jar full and just pouring them in.

    Reply

  11. Caroline
    08/04/2017

    Would it be okay to make this earlier in the day and then put it on a low setting for an hour or so before serving?

    Reply

  12. Tiddley
    08/19/2017

    I am definitely going to try this – thanks for sharing. AND if you have time to bake anything from scratch along with raising kids, working, laundry, dishes, yard work, shopping, cooking, etc. etc. – then you are seriously blessed.

    Reply

  13. Karen
    08/27/2017

    Planning to make for our church ladies tonight.My son makes and its great !

    Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      08/28/2017

      Yay Karen! I am so glad to hear that!

      Kate

      Reply

  14. Brenda
    09/13/2017

    What size crockpot, does it matter?

    Reply

    • Michelle
      04/20/2019

      I think it said 4-6 qt crockpot

      Reply

  15. Debbie Nobles
    09/14/2017

    This looks like it would be a delicious chocolate cake recipe for even my best friend that is absolutely the pickiest of the pickiest of eaters.. even when it comes to deserts!
    Thank you so much for sharing your recipe.

    Reply

  16. Melissa Gatlin
    09/25/2017

    Hi this does look very good and really easy. I can’t wait to make however I was wondering if you can use a different chocolate cake mix instead of the traditional? I accidentally bought the same Pillsbury chocolate cake mix, but instead of traditional its moist supreme. Will that work?

    Reply

    • Jen
      10/06/2017

      Yes you can use any mix, and Icing. I made a strawberry cake and used lemon icing last week. Strawberry lemon cake was awesome.

      Reply

  17. Kay
    09/25/2017

    Do you preheat the crock-pot or dump all in and then turn it on? Never was sure about that part.

    Reply

    • Kelly
      09/25/2017

      Kay, I just made a similar recipe the other day. I put the ingredients in my crockpot, then turned it on. It took about 2.5 hours to cook from the time I turned it on.

      Reply

  18. Brandy
    10/02/2017

    Hi what size crockpot and would a casserole crock work?

    Reply

    • Karla
      01/24/2019

      It says 4-6 qt.

      Reply

  19. Showmegal
    10/03/2017

    I bought chocolate frosting instead of fudge frosting and was wondering if anyone else used chocolate instead of the fudge and if so how was it?

    Reply

    • Jen
      10/06/2017

      Can’t say on taste of the chocolate over the fudge, but it will work. I mix and match , you can use any mix, and Icing. I made a strawberry cake and used lemon icing last week. Strawberry lemon cake was awesome.

      Reply

    • Jennifer
      11/15/2017

      How did it turn out with the chocolate icing. I live in Canada and we cant get fudge icing here. Only chocolate or milk chocolate.

      Reply

      • Joan
        11/19/2017

        I used chocolate icing and it was fine!

        Reply

  20. Eddie
    11/01/2017

    Looks like two other people asked this already without it being answered: What size (quart capacity) is the crack pot? This will matter for cooking times and product consistency. Thank you in advance!

    Reply

  21. Billy Anne Crews
    11/12/2017

    Just mentioning that those worries about ingredients in store bought mix and other things… you can buy all organic cake mix and frosting. It’s not from scratch… but it will lack the stack of crap in the regular brands most people use. This is a quick fix to a dessert!

    Reply

  22. Joan
    11/19/2017

    Tried this lava cake in my crockpot and after 2.5 hrs it was mushy and needed to cook longer. Maybe 3-4 hrs. Guess it depends on the kind of crockpot you have.

    Reply

  23. Marie
    11/21/2017

    Could you use caramel chips

    Reply

  24. Frances Gilbert
    11/24/2017

    What setting for crock pot?? Mine only has low and high. Thank you much…

    Reply

    • Sherryl
      01/08/2018

      High

      Reply

  25. Kayren
    11/24/2017

    Do you bake the cake first? Second question is if you dont bake cake do you mix indredients up first?

    Reply

    • Sherryl
      01/08/2018

      Prepare cake mix according to box instructions and pour raw cake mix in crockpot then add icing and then chocolate chips

      Reply

  26. bill fitzenreiter
    12/10/2017

    I made a mistake and got milk chocolate brownie mix would this work instead of cake mix

    Reply

  27. Valerie
    12/15/2017

    Could you double this and use the same time?

    Reply

    • Sherryl
      01/08/2018

      No, it would take about an hour and half more cooking time

      Reply

  28. Dee
    12/17/2017

    Curious to know why it says 2&1/2 hrs then says 1 he cook time??

    Reply

  29. Jennipher
    12/21/2017

    Do you set the temp at high or low?

    Reply

  30. Pam
    12/30/2017

    Thank you for the delicious recipe that you posted for the Lava Cake. I will be making it on New Years Day for Adults and Children alike. It is such a treat for all! It has become one of my favorite winter recipes! So simple!! Thanks again!

    Reply

  31. Hayley
    01/07/2018

    Do you set it on high, medium or low?

    Reply

  32. Sherryl
    01/08/2018

    5 stars
    Cook on high for 2 – 2 1/2 hours
    Use prepared cake mix raw.
    Use 4 to 6 quart crock pot.

    All questions answered, btw they were all included in the instructions

    Thx for a great recipe

    Reply

  33. Sarah
    01/14/2018

    I have 2 questions:
    1. Can you cook it on low for a longer time(as in while I’m at work so it’s ready when I get home)?
    2. It is still good to reheat if it’s not all eaten in the first sitting?

    Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      01/22/2018

      Hi Sarah, I am not sure because I haven’t tried cooking it longer on a lower time, so sorry about that.

      Yes, it is good to reheat – we ate it as a leftover and it was great!

      I hope you enjoy it!

      Kate

      Reply

  34. Noreen Bills
    01/20/2018

    Thanks for sharing. I love quick and easy recipes. Quick question – Should I use some nonstick spray?

    Reply

  35. Linda Niedzinski
    01/22/2018

    I wont be coming back to this site! This site is a joke. Why is it, when women get to talking, in this case, typing, they always start something, stupid of course, arguing back and forth about how they used the word too! COme on ladies, unless you are all ten years old

    Reply

  36. Linda K.
    01/25/2018

    I’m thinking of making this for a Superbowl party. Is it too messy to remove from the crock to carry to the party? Should I leave it in the crock and serve from there?

    Reply

  37. Shazam
    01/29/2018

    I loved these questions & comments. I was wondering if you stick a possum in your crockpot & cover it with choc chips would it be just as good??

    Reply

  38. AC
    01/30/2018

    How many servings does this make? Thank you. 🙂

    Reply

  39. Chris
    01/30/2018

    Okay my 8 year old and I did this tonight foe my wife’s birthday.

    Tastes amazing, didn’t turn out right. For some reason our chocolate fudge frosting (same stuff as video) sank to bottom of mix and spread out. So when I pulled cake out the “lava” was literally molten lava at the bottom and not spread throughout the cake.

    I thought maybe I should cook the batter about a half hour next time and then add the frosting.
    Tips? Tricks?

    Reply

  40. Melanie Haywood
    01/31/2018

    to the person being rude about cake mixes, have you ever seen all the extra ingredients listed, ? lots of not good for you, junk plus allergens I would net to make w/o wheat flour. mixes have soy in them which is a huge allergen as well

    Reply

  41. Vickie Gibson
    02/04/2018

    Cook on High or low?

    Reply

  42. Juli
    02/08/2018

    Made this for my granddaughter and she LOVED IT!!!! She wanted a “lava cake” and I was pinched for time. So your recipe was a true blessing! Thank you for sharing.

    Reply

  43. Joan oneill
    02/14/2018

    Crock pot on high or low

    Reply

  44. Patti
    02/14/2018

    My niece makes something similar, only she uses cake mix (mixed as directions call for on the box) with uncooked pudding in the middle. Cooks 4 hours in the crock pot.
    By the way, some people have to stick with a gluten free diet, due to celiac disease or allergies, which is why they might not want to use a boxed cake mix.

    Reply

  45. Lindabklyn
    03/18/2018

    4 stars
    Made it this morning, use chocolate cake, hot pink vanilla frosting, espresso powder and chocolate chips.
    Taste very good.

    Reply

  46. Lisa
    04/08/2018

    In the crockpot now! Time is set…making this for my husband’s birthday hope he loves it ❤
    How do I add a photo?

    Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      04/17/2018

      Hi Lisa! So excited that you’re making this, it’s one of our favorites!

      Kate

      Reply

    • Michelle
      04/20/2019

      Why size cake mix did you use? ONE for an 8×8 Or 9×13?

      Reply

      • Kate Sorensen
        04/22/2019

        9×13

        Reply

  47. Sheri
    06/01/2018

    5 stars
    Just cooking the cake alone (Thinking about a Poke Cake) would the cook time be the same? Or do you think it should be less? Because the pudding and icing is added after the cake is cooked and cooled.

    Reply

    • Jamie Lequeux
      06/05/2018

      I did not see a printable version as stated in the explanation on line. Could you please send me a printable version?

      Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      06/14/2018

      Hi Sheri, Sorry for the late response. I am not sure as I’ve never tried this.

      Let me know how it goes.

      Kate

      Reply

  48. Missy Chavez
    08/11/2018

    Just FYI – 1st of all, I made yes and it is amazingly delicious! BUT here’s the FYI part – I have an older cock pot at least 15 years old and it took mine about 4 to 5 hours to cook all the way through

    Reply

  49. Sandy
    08/15/2018

    No matter what kind of cake mix I use. Sound delicious
    Just wow on all comments. If you don’t like move on. Im legally blind so please make fun of my typing if youyou want I don’t give a rats @@@.
    Thank you for sharing this I could read the typing with my magnifying glass just fine.

    Reply

  50. Pat Wilks
    09/05/2018

    I made this for my husband and grandchildren. It was awesome with a scoop of vanilla ice cream! They loved it. Will definitely be making this again.

    Reply

  51. JoAnn
    10/04/2018

    I’m going to try it using Nutella instead of frosting.

    Reply

  52. Aurelia Fernandez
    11/05/2018

    This recipe of the Lava cake, is just a simple way to make a cake and if you want to try it, try it. Don’t have to try to show anyone if it’s healthy, or change the sharing of a recipe. I’m going to try it, thank you.

    Reply

  53. Amanda
    01/16/2019

    What temp does the crock pot go on? Whatever the box says?

    Reply

    • Karla
      01/24/2019

      I’m just curious. Why all the questions about, time, heat setting, mixing cake, spraying with non stick spray, size of crock pot, ECT? Everyone of those questions are answered in the recipe. Just read the recipe.

      Reply

  54. Michelle
    04/20/2019

    Is the cake mix for a 9×13 pan or 8×8. Does that effect the amount of time if it’s an 8×8 mix?

    Reply

  55. Ron Nelson
    04/30/2019

    Ok, I get it. I DID not read all comments, however, enough to know the big issue seems to be box over scratch. Well, I’ve been around the block a few times and I feel I have heard a lot of different “warnings” down through the years about various foods, chemicals, ingredients in general and I also have seen the same warnings disputed or contradicted a year or two later. That being said, I don’t believe anyone can PROVE one way or another what does or does not potentially cause sufficient harm that avoiding same would make that much difference. So, eat what you want within reason or common sense and let others do the same. As Charlie Brown might say; “Good Grief”!

    Reply

  56. Lou
    05/17/2019

    At my house we’re busy. Easy is a good thing. Sometimes you like quick and easy. Sometimes you like gourmet. If you don’t like it, don’t read it. Go to other
    posts. See. Easy.

    Reply

  57. Chris
    07/29/2019

    It says two hours in one place and two and a half in another which is it

    Reply

  58. Julia
    09/14/2019

    Can you use milk chocolate frosting

    Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      09/25/2019

      Hi Julia, Sure!

      Reply

  59. Linnea Gimby-Crespo
    10/03/2019

    Where is the printable recipe for Chocolate Lava Cake?!

    Reply

  60. Shareon White
    10/11/2019

    How is it if you don’t eat right away. We will be having company to play cards and usually have dessert several hours after we eat supper.

    Reply

  61. LaChelle
    12/17/2019

    Has anyone doubled this recipe? I would assume it would take a bit longer to cook.

    Reply

  62. Michael
    01/19/2021

    I could be wrong on this and Someone can correct Me if I am but looking at the pictures it looks like the frosting has been chilled for some time. Do Any of Y’all know whether or not the frosting should be chilled before putting it into the slow cooker?? Thanks for the help in advance.

    Reply

  63. Kris
    02/13/2022

    Would this work in an instant pot with the cake setting?

    Reply

    • Kate Sorensen
      02/14/2022

      Hi Kris, I’m sorry, I am just not sure. I haven’t tried that.

      Kate

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Back to top
mobile desktop